Showing posts with label Latte Math. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Latte Math. Show all posts

Feb 13, 2007

Latte-nomics vs. FinGho-nomics

Folks, time to put this Latte story to test. I have heard this story far too many times from far too many 'experts'. It has even found a place in some bestseller books that sell a million plus copies. I thought I should compare the Latte math with the math of a FinGho Walker to see who does better.

Latte-nomics 101

Your daily savings by giving up a Starbucks Latte ($4) and settling for a 'no frills' coffee ($1): $3

Imagine you are 30 years old and do this every working day for the next 35 years. There are 241 working days/year (52 wks*5 days/wk. - 9 holidays - 10 vacation or sick days). You'll save $723 per year. Investing this money in a broad portfolio of no-brainer index funds can yield an average annual return of 8%. Over a 35 year period with annual compounding, your daily Latte sacrifice would yield in the neighborhood of $125,000 when you turn 65. Great!

As impressive as this figure sounds, don't discount the sacrifice. Imagine going without an exceptionally brewed cup of coffee each morning for the rest of your working life (which can be the only comfort on some miserable days) , i.e. for 35 years or 8,435 working days!

Compare this with the case of a FinGho Walker who refuses to give up this daily indulgence but focuses on what's important.

FinGho-nomics 101

A FinGho Walker would not deny himself such simple indulgences but rather be strong-willed about resisting the Madison Avenue-driven symbols of lifestyle, typically seen in a major purchase we all are confronted with every few years....buying a car. Instead of buying a $35,000 luxury car just because he can (and to be told later by 'experts' to give up his daily latte to make ends meet!) , a FinGho Walker will buy a reliable used car like a Honda or Toyota, available for about $10,000. Both the 'showy' luxury car and the reliable used car will do a fine job of taking us to work every morning. I would argue the used car will make you a more relaxed driver knowing that the inevitable dents, accidents and repairs along your commute will cost a whole lot less to fix compared to a luxury car. Aside from stress-related advantages, here's the math comparing a reliable used car buyer who loves her morning latte vs. a stressed out luxury car buyer who has grudgingly given up the morning latte.

For the sake of apples-to-apples comparison, I assume both put down $10,000 for their cars. By buying a reliable used car, the FinGho Walker will save about $37,620 over 5 years or simply stated, an annualized amount of $7,524 (See table at the end of the post for details). Let's assume our FinGho Walker friend invests these savings in the same no-brainer portfolio (8% annualized return) as our 'Latte-less' friend. When both of them are 65 years old (assuming the used car and new car are both replaced every 5 years), the FinGho Walker would have accumulated $1.3 million more, while enjoying great coffee each morning! This is more than 10 times the amount accumulated by our friend who has to drive past Starbucks each morning and be reminded of his Latte sacrifice.

What's more, even if our FinGho Walker friend did this for just the first 5 years till she is 35 and then proceeded to buy brand new luxury cars every 5 years till she retired at 65, she comes out way ahead. By investing the car savings during the first 5 years and nothing more ever after, she would have accumulated over $444,000 more by the time she turns 65! This is still more than three times what our friend would have accumulated by giving up a refreshing daily Latte. This example illustrates the power of compounding and the rewards of making sensible decisions where they matter most.

Now tell me, is giving up the Latte everyday really worthwhile compared to making sensible purchase decisions in the major discretionary areas of your life?








































Luxury Car BuyerReliable Used Car BuyerSavings Over 5 Years
Purchase Cost ($10K down for both)$35,000$10,000$25,000
Annual Interest (5 year loan; 5% rate)$774$0 (cash purchase)$3,870
Annual Insurance$2,500$1,000$7,500
Annual Property Taxes (~1%)$350$100$1,250
TOTAL SAVINGS$37,620